The Nature of Doctrine: Religion and Theology in a Postliberal Age an understanding of doctrine that will aid ecumenical discussion, Lindbeck sketches in this. In addition to his account of the nature of religion, George Lindbeck also addresses the relationship between Christianity and other religions, the resolution of. Friday 16th November GMT – Sunday 18th November GMT: Payment facilities will be unavailable on Taylor & Francis Online during this period due.
In this model, faith describes an inner experience of divinity, one that is shared in essence with other religious traditions, such that the different religions are simply different expressions of what is held in common. This is the view that roots theology in experiences of God. This groundbreaking work lays the foundation for a theology based on a cultural-linguistic approach to religion and a regulative or rule theory of doctrine.
I had to read this in one sitting for class this week, so it’s entirely possible my confusion and issues with the work will be resolved once I’m allowed more time to digest and re-read portions that were murky to me.
It is the text, so to speak, which absorbs the world, rather than the world the text. For those who know, it goes without saying that you have to read George Lindbeck at some point in seminary. Reversing the lindbefk between the inner religious experiences to the outer world the subjective emphasis of experiential-expressivists who call external symbolism as mere expressions – to that of an outer world as the source for such inner experiences, Lindbeck counters the relativizing tendencies in the other model liberal experiential-expressivism.
Linkbeck’s conclusions are the starting point for a lot of the theology books I have enjoyed reading. This groundbreaking work lays the foundation for a theology based on a cultural-linguistic approach to religion and a regulative or rule theory of doctrine. Although lindbec gives some attention to the propositional model, that is not the focus of his concern.
Very few theologians spark a generation s of scholarship, much less just one work of those theologians. Not literally heavy, as its only pages. Read, highlight, and take notes, across web, tablet, and phone. If you do too, then check this one out.
That would be the experiential-expressive model of liberalism. Reframe theological discourse in such a way that it is possible to be relevant to contemporary concerns and culture while at the same time remaining faithful to historic Creedal Christianity. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. Sep 11, David rated it really liked it Shelves: If I want a good story and beauty, then why not go to Tolkien, for example? Therefore the point is to draw the world into the biblical world, not the other way around.
In this, Lindbeck seemed to have succumbed to the relativizing tendencies that he dochrine set to counter. But, I’m not convinced that Lindbeck is entirely successful. In any event, the brilliance and influence of the work are undeniable, even if I do have some seemingly significant quibbles with it. Overall, this is a challenging and good book for those interested in theology. David rated it it was amazing Feb 24, The cognitive-propositionalist truth-statement and truth-claims and experiential-expressivist emotive and subjective approaches are limited, or at least they do not facilitate religious dialogue well.
Doctrune library Help Advanced Book Search.
The Nature of Doctrine
To be completely fair: It’s absorbing how people talk about God that forms how to talk about God. In other words, cultural-linguistic approach prioritizes communal or common language about God or religious objects.
He is the author of several books, including The Church in a Postliberal Age. A most worthwhile read for those interested in this sort of thing. Now I finally know some of the alternative views of understanding religion propositional and experiential-expressive and I know what the “liberal” in “post-liberal” means understanding all religion as starting from essentially the same human experiences that we all share. To learn theology is not to read some propositions either. His critique lindheck propositionalists is their preoccupation for certitude, which according to Lindbeck is not possible on this side of human existence.
George Lindbeck, Nature of Doctrine Critical Review Essay | David Muthukumar –
Lindbecks book is one of the defining works of post-liberal theology, perhaps the most interesting theology to come about in the latter half of the 20th Century along with deconstructive theology and radical orthodoxy. Religion and Theology in a Postliberal Age. I am not linndbeck Lindbeck avoids the same critique that Langdon Gilkey delivered to and subsequently finished neo-Orthodoxy: Other editions – View all The Nature of Doctrine: He contends that if we can devise an alternative approach so that can make sense of the intertwining of variability and invariability of doctrines, then it will be conducive for ecumenical purposes.
Jul 10, Sarah rated it it was docttrine Shelves: Lindbeck’s thesis is as follows: Lists with This Book. One of the few books I’ve rated with 5 stars, mostly because naturs the book’s influence. First, if theology is just a particular community’s talk about God, then can theology be reduced to ecclesiology doctrine of the church? Theology then is not really about God or Jesus, but how God or Jesus is perceived by this or that church.
Lindbeck dives into a lot from this, from inter-denomination discussions to inter-religious lindbdck. Enter the email address you signed up with and we’ll email you a reset link.
Many Religions and the One True Faith. In this approach, religious meanings and significance vary while doctrines remain the same, and also conversely, meanings remain same while doctrines undergo alterations. Fo many ways, this is the primary struggle Linndbeck have in my own theology and academic life as a Creedal Christian at an institution with little time for classical theological formulations. Put differently, if theology is just language, then does it matter if that language is historically accurate — e.
Anyway, the second approach is the emotive-expressivist if I recall the name right, the book is in my basement right now and I don’t feel like retrieving it! I don’t mean by that simply that he doesn’t speak to how religions initially come into existence, but rather, why is it that in evangelistic religions like Christianity, the Gospel is proclaimed as a series of truths to be believed before it is a language to be spoken and a culture to be embraced.
Speaking of which, growing up conservative, this would be my background.
Privacy & Cookies Policy
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.